The Muppets comes out two weeks from now and - as I declared on Twitter - that means you get two weeks of Muppets-related Theater Hopper comics.
I'll be frank and admit that I don't entirely know what to expect from The Muppets. I've been in lockdown mode on this one for a while. It has been extraordinarily hard to do this because it seems like Disney is practically littering the internet with clips from the film. I'm even doing my best to avoid the commercials.
I hope I haven't gotten my hopes up too far. There's been inklings of dissaproval swirling around the movie from people in the know - most notably, Frank Oz. The creator of Miss Piggy, Fozzy Bear and original Muppeteer has been quoted as saying that the new movie sacrifices the integrity of the characters for the sake of making cheap jokes, and rewrites their personas and relationships in a way that “creates a false history that the characters were forced to act out for the sake of this movie.” There's even been talk of some of the Muppeteer's who performed in the movie wanting to take their name off of it.
The main complaint seems to be that writer/actor Jason Segel had the right intentions with the movie, but that basically... it's not what Jim Henson would have wanted.
Personally, I see both sides of the story. Yes, it's important to maintain the integrity of The Muppets. There is something unquantifiable about these characters that people have fallen in love with and we don't want to see the sullied.
But to disparage the film because it's not what Jim Henson would have done is simple short-sighted. Where would Disney be if they stopped producing cartoons after Walt Disney died? At some point, you have to prepare for the reality that the characters you may have had a hand in creating really don't belong to you anymore. They belong to the people who believe in them. If you want your work to live on, it might not hurt to be a little magnanimous about it and hand them down to the next generation.
Oz's comments in the Hollywood Report article strike me as a little possessive in a "get off my lawn" kind of way. If the new Muppets movie gets it wrong in some way, let them go back and try again. Were the Muppets fully formed characters out of the box when they were introduced 50 years ago? No, the evolved over time. There's got to be a learning curve to this.
But to lock the characters in amber because you don't want their integrity sullied? Well, that's just selfish.
What are your thoughts about The Muppets? Are you looking forward to it? Specifically, I'm kind of interested in what Gen Y's reaction to The Muppets will be. Do they feel left out of the loop since The Muppets were essentially a lost property during the 90s? Do they have the same affinity for the characters that older audiences do? Will the elixir of nostalgia be as potent among that audience?
Leave your comments below! I'd love to hear them! And, as always, if you could use the ShareThis tool at the bottom of the blog post to share the Muppet-y goodness, I'd appreciate it!
Have a great week!
